Home/Featured Cars/Totaled to Making the Big Decision: The Final Chapter

Totaled to Making the Big Decision: The Final Chapter

Part 5: The Final Choice: Meet My New Car (and Why it Won Me Over)

Hi, it’s me, Nicole, again, for the last time in this series, with the final part of Totaled to Test Drive: The Search for My New Car. If you’ve been following along, you know this hasn’t just been about buying a new car—it’s been a journey!

For those new here, I unexpectedly had to say goodbye to my Jeep Patriot in Part 1, then test drove some of the most exciting 2025 SUVs out there—the Toyota 4Runner in Part 2, the Ford Bronco in Part 3, and most recently, the Jeep Wrangler in Part 4—this blog series has been full of twists, turns, and test drives!

And, now, finally, it’s the time we’ve all been waiting for (or more specifically, me!)—the moment for the big reveal! For the last time, follow along to find out which SUV won me over and why I’m buying this one instead of the other two.

Which SUV Did I Finally Choose?

It’s the 2025 Jeep Wrangler! It shouldn’t be a surprise, given the strong case it made for itself in Part 4. It checked all the right boxes: refined, rugged, capable, and moreover, it comes packed with a personality that goes perfectly well with not just me, but also Cooper and Murphy. I loved my Patriot, and the Wrangler felt the closest to it—it’s like coming back to a newly renovated home, with the same cozy feeling and comfort, just upgraded!

The interior feels great—refined with luxurious finishing touches but still unapologetically Jeep. The tech features are accessible and easy to use, exactly what I wanted. Then there was the cherry on top: the 0% financing option, which worked perfectly within my budget, along with the fact that I’m juggling a car payment and mortgage as well.

Why I Chose the Wrangler Over The Rest?

If you don’t know already, I test drove two other SUVs in the previous parts of this series before choosing the Wrangler.

  • The 2025 Toyota 4Runner was a great choice, but it was slightly over my budget. Plus, it was a lot bulkier and bigger than what I needed for me and my dogs.
  • On the other hand, I couldn’t get over the fact that the 2025 Ford Bronco felt more like a toy, and the ride was not as smooth and confident as I wanted it to be.
  • Taking all this into consideration while test driving the Jeep Wrangler, it made me feel like myself again behind the wheel—the kind of driver who wants to explore, camp, paddleboard, and take the long way home with my canine crew. I truly did feel a strong connection with the Wrangler!

    What I’ve Learned Through All of This

    Losing your car to an unexpected accident (or, more accurately, due to someone’s poor driving skills and road sense) is never easy. It throws you off, especially when that car has been with you for so many years. But it opened the door for me to upgrade to something new, something still within my budget but also further improve my life. Through this whole journey of test driving some of the best options out there, it taught me:

  • A lot about patience, perspective, and the importance of taking my time when making a big decision like this.
  • It helped me think through the process as a whole, including what my budget would be, the features I want, the kind of ride I want, and how it fits into my day-to-day life.
  • By the time I test drove the Wrangler, I had gained clarity on what I wanted and what I didn’t for my new car. Having that clarity helped me make an informed decision.
  • Ultimately, it’s not just about picking a nice-looking vehicle; it’s about finding one that suits your lifestyle, meets your needs, and makes you feel comfortable behind the wheel.
  • How Cars.ca Helped in This Process

    Leading the retail finance team at Cars.ca, it only made sense to use it while looking for a new car, but I only really knew it from one side of the coin, behind the scenes. But, from a buyer’s perspective, I kid you not, the moment I started browsing the platform, it even surprised me how much I was spoiled by a multitude of options. Best part? I could filter my search based on my nearby location, so test driving the top options was super easy for me and my busy schedule, as I could simply search for the best dealerships around me and—boom—I knew where I was going. I even used the Saved Search option when looking at different models so I could quickly compare them with what I had previously browsed.

    Overall, Cars.ca played a crucial role in making the process smoother, faster, and way less overwhelming. Sure, I know I’m biased, but it truly did give me the tools to stay organized, save time, and ultimately feel confident in the decision I was making. So, if you’re in the market looking for a ride, give our Cars.ca platform a try and explore the best deals, indicated by the platform’s unique price badging.

    Big thanks to all the dealerships that welcomed me for test drives—every team I met was incredibly helpful, professional, and made the experience easy and enjoyable.

    At last, thank you for following along with me through this series. I hope you enjoyed the ride as much as I did, and maybe even learned a thing or two about what goes into choosing a car.

    With nearly a decade in the EINC Toronto office under her belt and a laugh that can be heard through still images, Nicole leads the retail finance team for EDealer and Cars.ca. Outside of work, she can often be found on outdoor adventures with her dogs Cooper and Murphy, spending time with family and friends, or cheering on the Tiger-Cats at Hamilton Stadium.